I have never made a homemade pizza crust before. That’s three for three on the ‘new experiences’ front for this blog!
I busted out my trusty baking cookbook (that has amazing and detailed instructions) and decided for this first pizza I would hand knead the dough. Next time I’ll use my stand mixer instead of kneading by hand. This recipe calls for yeast, which seemed appropriate.
Yeast is one of those things that can be pretty easy to work with, if you know what you’re doing. It can also be super intimidating. I feel only vaguely confident with yeast. This time I got pretty lucky.
This pizza dough recipe is pretty basic: flour, water, yeast, sugar, and salt. There’s enough for two 12 to 14 inch pizza crusts.
The yeast got all foamy. I wasn’t as exacting with the water temperature and the time as I should have been.
Added the flour.
Mixed it up.
Up next was the hand kneading for 8-10 minutes. Unfortunately kneading is a two-handed job, and I didn’t have any assistants around to photograph the process. I will admit, kneading the dough was pretty soothing. It was a good way to get out a little stress.
I let the dough rise for about 2 hours, and then punched it down (beware – don’t punch the bowl), covered it in plastic wrap, and let it rise in the fridge overnight. I wish I’d caught a picture of it while it was on the first rise, it almost blew up out of the bowl. (This is maybe a sign related to my poor timing skills with the yeast).
The next day, I got the dough out to rest and started on prepping my tomatoes for the Pizza Margherita.
Blanch, peel, & seed. Then they’re chopped. I didn’t get quite all of the moisture out, which was a problem when baking.
Prepping for the margherita (that’s sliced basil on the right).
Divide it in half, cover, & let the dough rest a little longer.
Rolling it out. It’s much stretchier than a traditional dough, and rolling it often involves the dough shrinking back in on itself a bit.
Trusty assistant, Chad, sliced the mozzarella.
After I rolled out the crust, we decided to give the whole pizza toss thing a chance. It worked pretty well, and I think stretched things out a little more. It didn’t call for it in the recipe and I admittedly have no idea if this is the right kind of pizza dough to toss. This may have contributed to the tougher nature of the crust, things might have gotten overworked.
In the oven.
I definitely don’t think I’ve mastered things, but I was pretty happy with the results. The original recipe called for heating up a pizza stone for 30 minutes, and then placing a prepped pizza onto the stone. Once the pizza was ready, it was to heavy to move, or I didn’t have the appropriate tools.
Also I wasn’t in love with this margherita recipe. The tomatoes still had too much moisture. I think I’d do it with a really basic pizza sauce next time, instead of fresh tomatoes.
The crust I think was a little too thick and dense, which may have meant there was something wrong with my kneading, the yeast sat too long or something else. It did not reheat well.
I’m looking forward to trying it again! Let me know if you have any suggestions or tips or help for things I did wrong/can do better next time!